Dear mid:
I work at a small college, and for 20 years I have been an active and enthusiastic participant in college life – I attend all the faculty meetings, I speak up in all the listening meetings, I fill out all the surveys. I’ve been the chair of my department and of all the big committees, and I’m widely respected by my colleagues and often asked for advice. Recently, I put my name in the ring for an open administrative position. I wasn’t hired and I am both shocked and devastated. I received all the platitudes in the world about how valued I am, but now I just feel like I’m stuck in a place that doesn’t really have room to grow and with people who don’t really want me doing bigger work. I can’t move right now, since my husband’s job is here and my kids are in middle school. Right now, what I really want to do is just quit everything: every committee, every meeting. But I’m worried about burning bridges. I’m angry and frustrated and embarrassed, and I just don’t know what to do at all.
– Unenthusiastic participant
Dear Unenthusiastic:
Jamie: I’m really sorry. It sucks not to be hired, especially by people you know. First things first: take some time to do some real wallowing. Eat your feelings, start a workout program, adopt a puppy, whatever. And then, to be honest, I don’t think your impulse to quit everything is a bad one!
When I had a similar experience, I complained to my sister about feeling like I had to keep plodding along for fear of burning bridges. She said something that stopped me in my tracks: “The thing is,” she said, “there is no bridge.”
There is no bridge. There’s no bridge! The bridge is a bs lie! I mean, sometimes there’s a bridge. I’ve burnt some and I’ve had mine burned. But sometimes the fantasy of the bridge keeps us stuck. You’re doing things in the hopes that sometimes, it’ll be noticed and you’ll be the chosen one.
Sam: I’m so the “pick me” girl at work, constantly laying myself across broken slats to be the bridge and hoping they’ll look down and notice while they are walking me. Seeking external validation from the institution is a trap, one that I’m a sucker for as well.
Jamie: Yeah, my nieces have called me a “try-hard,” and that’s probably true. Many academics are the pick-me try-hards – it’s how we got here in the first place.
I suggest doing something that’s going to feel icky/stupid/basic: Take a beat and ask yourself why you applied for the position, beyond general ambition or even money. Repeat these questions as needed until you are not always screaming back, “I don’t want to do this kind of soul-searching, Jamie, I just want to rage out.”
Were there things you wanted to do with it? Skills you wanted to learn? Things you wanted to change or try? List those things. Yes, on a piece of paper (or computer document, if you’re not a Luddite like me). I think it’s good to separate what we want to actually do from the institution’s approval/denial machine.
Sam: I like that idea Jamie, because to be honest: I feel tired just trying to ask myself what lights me up, or what I personally find satisfying. I haven’t thought about what I want or care about for so long. I feel like I’ve been the happy helper for the projects of others. And we’ve been bosses at whacking moles as they pop up– or as other people point to them for us to whack.
I’ve said yes to all of these projects with no real compass for myself or my finite energy. Here you are: jack of all trades, agenda-setter and compensated for none, and asked by everyone to help fix/run things while they get titles and pay bumps and books written.
My working hypothesis is that saying and seeing and feeling some bigger yeses might make it easier to see and say the nos.
Jamie: I’ve been experimenting with what would happen if I didn’t wait for approval, for someone to choose me. Like when Sam and I put our heads together for this column and The New Network– we just wanted to find folks, inside or outside of our own institutions, to learn or do what we wanted to try to do (programming, budgeting, conflict resolution, whathaveyou). We were just kind of sick of waiting to be picked first in gym class.
Sam: It took lots of painful try-harding and awkward chats with our own heads and each other, but choosing one yes helped to satisfy my happy helper and, I think, my future self. Like, I’m still lying down on the bridge, but maybe I’m like on my side, texting a friend and re-watching The Sopranos and ordering roasted eggplant on my pizza because it’s my pizza, damn it? It’s not perfect– it’s iterative, for sure– but it’s something!
Jamie: Yeah, this is a real revise-and-resubmit situation. When all else fails, I take my grandma’s advice from when I was a kindergartner: Eat a banana, take a nap, and try something new. I’m still doing all those things on the bridge, but it’s helping me baby step to the side and imagine other ways to suspend myself.
Want to share your mid story or ask/vent through a mid question? And /or do you want to find some folks in the same professional (head)space? Talk to us here!
Feature Image Courtesy of WikiCommons

What is mid.?
Technology, ideology, and austerity have us unmoored and unmoved—stuck in the middle of this moment. Professors, writers, and thinking humans can’t work like we used to. Increasingly, the institutions, organizations, and affiliations seem impossible, or maybe they seem not worth pouring our energy into. Short of quitting and becoming small-batch strawberry gardeners, what can we do?
mid. does not offer trite advice on how to garner other job offers or move up in your industry.
We aren’t trying to get you to optimize your life. Instead, it starts from the fundamental recognition that many of us are stuck. Maybe we’re in the middle because we can’t move for family, geographical, financial, or personal reasons. Maybe we’ve done everything we can think of, been on every committee, joined every group, and still can’t seem to find ways forward, whether scholarly, creatively, institutionally, or personally. Maybe we’re middle-aged or mid-career or just, as the Gen Alphas say, mid, for several overlapping reasons, external and internal.
mid. aims to give practical but outside-of-the-box advice for folks who are in the middle place– advice that acknowledges that there are real obstacles to standard professional and creative counsel that can’t be unmoved. Following the long literary history of advice columns in periodical culture from the late 17th century through to today’s Reel advice landscape, we draw on personal experience and expert analysis to provide the kind of empathetic and honest thoughts about the writing and thinking dilemmas we often don’t talk about. We give advice and commiseration on how to move: if not forward, then sideways through the middle.
Who we are:
Jamie is an underslept professor, parent, author, bureaucrat, Little League snack-bringer and endless car-pooler. She writes to-do lists on scraps of paper and leaves cold mugs of half-drunk coffee everywhere.
Sam is a professor, author, journeywoman editor & administrator, parent, partner, petty text friend, & overall tired human. She plans to be more interesting as soon as she gets her inbox count down.
Follow us if not our advice on Instagram
Discover more from Avidly
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


